Blog | Stiles Associates

2025 Stiles Associates Hiring Checklist

Written by Caitlin Cassidy & David Portney | Feb 12, 2025 12:12:53 PM

This comprehensive hiring checklist is designed to streamline the recruitment process and ensure all critical steps are meticulously followed. From defining the role and creating a compelling job description to partnering with an executive search firm and conducting thorough candidate assessments, this checklist covers every aspect of the hiring journey.

By closely adhering to these guidelines, organizations can enhance their ability to attract top-tier talent, make informed hiring decisions and ultimately build a strong, cohesive team that aligns with the company's strategic goals and culture.

Utilize this checklist to achieve a more efficient and effective hiring process (scroll for text only):

1. Define the role

  • Define how this role fits into the company's long-term strategy
  • Clarify who the role will report to and any direct reports
  • Clearly outline the job title and responsibilities
  • Identify key qualifications and experience needed
  • Determine essential skills and competencies
  • Establish cultural fit and leadership qualities

2. Partner with executive search firm

  • Internal hiring team and recruiters meet to ensure proper alignment and expectations
  • This helps the search process become more efficient
  • Discuss the role, company culture, expectations and current market
  • Confirm budget and compensation package
  • Agree on key milestones and deadlines for the hiring process

3. Create a job description

  • Work with recruiters to write a detailed and compelling job description
  • Include company overview, responsibilities and role-specific information
  • Highlight unique selling points to attract top talent

4. Kickoff call

  • Establish communication and reporting protocols
  • Set up weekly or biweekly syncs with internal stakeholders and recruiters
  • Agree on the search strategy and timeline
  • Iron out any lingering questions

5. Prepare interview process

  • Develop a structured process for when the internal hiring team begins interviewing candidates found and vetted by the recruiters
  • Identify interview panel members and their roles
  • It’s important to have this prepared before recruiters begin contacting candidates to reduce delays

6. Candidate sourcing

HANDLED BY EXECUTIVE RECRUITERS

  • Allow the recruiters to utilize their network and resources
  • Leverage their expertise in identifying potential candidates
  • Regularly review progress and recalibrate if needed

7. Screening and shortlisting candidates

HANDLED BY EXECUTIVE RECRUITERS

  • Recruiters conduct initial screenings and interviews
  • Recruiters send top candidates to the hiring team
  • Hiring team reviews candidate profiles and provides feedback

8. Assessment and evaluation

  • Conduct in-depth interviews with shortlisted candidates
  • Administer relevant assessments
  • Evaluate candidates against the defined criteria, including cultural fit
  • Debrief after each interview with the recruiters

9. Reference and background checks

HANDLED BY EXECUTIVE RECRUITERS

  • Recruiters conduct thorough reference and background checks
  • Verify employment history and qualifications
  • Check for potential red flags

10. Offer and negotiation

  • Work with recruiters to prepare a competitive offer package that meets or exceeds the current market
  • Present the offer to the selected candidate, including relocation assistance, bonuses and equity if needed
  • Negotiate terms and finalize the agreement

By working closely with an established executive search firm like Stiles Associates, the hiring manager can benefit from its specialized expertise in executive recruitment, ensuring a more efficient and effective search process.